New York Tenant’s Rights to Withhold Rent or “Repair and Deduct”

by ECL Writer
New York Tenant's Rights to Withhold Rent or “Repair and Deduct”

When it comes to renting a property in New York, tenants have certain rights and responsibilities that they must abide by. One of these rights is the ability to withhold rent or “repair and deduct” in certain circumstances. This means that if a landlord fails to make necessary repairs to a rental property, the tenant may be able to make the repairs themselves and deduct the cost from their rent payment. However, it is important for tenants to understand the circumstances under which this right applies and the proper steps to take in order to assert their rights.

The “repair and deduct” provision is a crucial tool for tenants to ensure that their living conditions are safe and habitable. Landlords are required by law to maintain the rental property in a habitable condition, and if they fail to do so, the tenant may be able to make the necessary repairs and deduct the cost from their rent. This provision gives tenants a way to hold landlords accountable for their obligations and ensures that they are living in a safe and livable space.

However, it is important to note that the right to “repair and deduct” is not an absolute right and there are specific steps that must be taken in order to assert this right. Tenants must provide proper notice to the landlord and give them a reasonable opportunity to make the necessary repairs. Additionally, the cost of the repairs must be reasonable and the repairs must be necessary to remedy a dangerous or hazardous condition.

In this article, Eastcoastlaws.com will explore the New York tenant’s rights to withhold rent or “repair and deduct” in detail. We will discuss the circumstances under which this right applies, the proper steps to take, and the limitations of this right. Whether you are a current tenant or are considering becoming a tenant in New York, it is important to understand your rights and responsibilities and how to assert them.

What Justifies Tenants Paying Less Rent in New York

In New York, tenants have the right to withhold rent or “repair and deduct” under certain circumstances. This means that if a landlord fails to maintain the rental property in a habitable condition, the tenant may be able to make the necessary repairs themselves and deduct the cost from their rent payment.

In order to justify paying less rent in New York, the following conditions must be met:

  • The landlord must be notified: The tenant must provide the landlord with proper notice of the necessary repairs. This may include written or verbal communication. The tenant must give the landlord a reasonable opportunity to make the necessary repairs before proceeding with the “repair and deduct” process.
  • The repairs must be necessary: The repairs must be necessary to remedy a dangerous or hazardous condition that affects the health, safety, or welfare of the tenant. Examples of such conditions may include a lack of heat, hot water, electricity, or a working toilet.
  • The cost of the repairs must be reasonable: The cost of the repairs must be reasonable and proportionate to the value of the rent. The tenant cannot make extensive or unreasonable repairs and deduct the cost from their rent.
  • The tenant must follow the proper procedure: The tenant must follow the proper procedure for making the repairs and deducting the cost from their rent payment. This includes obtaining necessary permits, if required, and obtaining receipts for the repairs.

It is important to note that the “repair and deduct” provision is a legal remedy that should only be used as a last resort. Before proceeding with this process, tenants are encouraged to try to resolve the issue with the landlord through communication and negotiation. If this is not possible, tenants may need to seek legal assistance to assert their rights.

Can You Withhold Rent For Repairs In NY?

Yes, you can withhold rent for repairs in New York, but you need to follow specific steps and procedures. In New York, if a landlord fails to make necessary repairs, a tenant can legally withhold rent, but only after following certain procedures.

First, the tenant must give the landlord written notice of the repair needed and give the landlord a reasonable time to make the repair. If the landlord does not make the repair, the tenant may then deduct the cost of the repair from their rent. However, the tenant must first follow certain steps to document the repair, such as obtaining an estimate for the repair cost and informing the landlord of the repair cost.

Additionally, the tenant must keep a portion of the rent equal to the cost of the repair in a separate, escrow account and inform the landlord of this in writing. The tenant may then use the money in the escrow account to make the repair if the landlord does not make the repair within a reasonable time. The tenant must also inform the local housing department of the repair issue and provide proof of the notice to the landlord.

It’s essential to note that a tenant can only withhold rent in cases where the repair is necessary to make the unit livable and safe, such as fixing a broken heating system, leaky roof, or inoperable plumbing. Withholding rent for minor cosmetic repairs or for grievances with the landlord is not allowed.

If a tenant does withhold rent without following the proper procedures, the landlord may take the tenant to court for eviction. Thus, it is crucial to understand the laws and procedures for withholding rent for repairs in New York and to seek legal counsel if necessary.

Can A Tenant Deduct Repairs From Their Rent In New York?

Yes, a tenant in New York can deduct the cost of repairs from their rent, but only under specific circumstances and after following certain procedures. A tenant can only deduct the cost of necessary repairs that the landlord fails to make after being given written notice and a reasonable time to make the repair. The tenant must also obtain an estimate for the repair cost, inform the landlord of the repair cost, and keep a portion of the rent equal to the repair cost in a separate escrow account.

The tenant must also inform the local housing department of the repair issue and provide proof of the notice to the landlord. Only then can the tenant use the money in the escrow account to make the repair if the landlord does not make the repair within a reasonable time. It’s important to note that tenants can only deduct repairs that are necessary to make the unit livable and safe, such as fixing a broken heating system or a leaky roof. Deductions for minor cosmetic repairs or for grievances with the landlord are not allowed.

If a tenant does deduct repairs from their rent without following the proper procedures, the landlord may take the tenant to court for eviction. Therefore, it’s crucial for tenants to understand the laws and procedures for deducting repairs from rent in New York and to seek legal counsel if necessary.

What Can I Do If My Landlord Does Not Do Repairs?

If your landlord does not make necessary repairs in your rental unit, there are several steps you can take in New York:

  • Give written notice: Provide written notice to your landlord detailing the necessary repairs that need to be made. Give them a reasonable time to make the repairs.
  • Document the issue: Take pictures, keep receipts, and make a record of any communication with your landlord.
  • Contact the local housing department: Report the issue to your local housing department. They may be able to inspect the unit and issue violations to your landlord.
  • Withhold rent: If your landlord does not make the necessary repairs after a reasonable time, you may be able to withhold rent. However, you must follow the proper procedures, including obtaining an estimate for the repair cost, informing the landlord of the repair cost, and keeping a portion of the rent in a separate escrow account.
  • Repair and deduct: If the necessary repairs are not made, you may be able to make the repairs yourself and deduct the cost from your rent. However, you must follow the proper procedures and keep records of all expenses.
  • Consider legal action: If the landlord still refuses to make the necessary repairs, you may have to consider legal action, such as filing a lawsuit in housing court.

It’s important to note that these steps must be followed carefully to protect your rights as a tenant. Before taking any action, it’s a good idea to seek advice from a legal professional to ensure that you are following the correct procedures and protecting your rights.

How Long Does A Landlord Have To Fix Something In New York?

In New York, there is no specific time frame for how long a landlord has to make repairs. However, the law requires that landlords make repairs in a reasonable time after being notified by the tenant. A reasonable time will depend on the severity of the repair needed and can range from a few days to several weeks.

If the repair is considered to be an emergency, such as a broken heating system in the winter, the landlord should make the repairs as soon as possible. For non-emergency repairs, the landlord should make the repairs within a reasonable time after being notified by the tenant.

If a landlord fails to make necessary repairs after a reasonable time, a tenant may be able to withhold rent or make the repairs themselves and deduct the cost from their rent. However, it’s important to follow the proper procedures, including giving written notice to the landlord, obtaining an estimate for the repair cost, and keeping a portion of the rent in a separate escrow account.

In case the landlord does not make the repairs in a reasonable time, the tenant may consider legal action, such as filing a complaint in housing court. However, it’s advisable to seek legal advice before taking any action.

New York State and Local Law on Rent Withholding, Repair-and-Deduct, and Landlord Retaliation

For state law on rent withholding, see N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 235-bSemans Family Ltd. Partnership v. Kennedy, 675 N.Y.S.2d 489 (N.Y. City Civ. Ct., 1998).

For state law on repair and deduction, see N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 235-b (only for emergency repairs such as a broken door lock); Jangla Realty Co. v. Gravagna 447 N.Y.S.2d 338 (Civ. Ct., Queens County, 1981).

For state law prohibiting landlord retaliation, see N.Y. Real. Prop. Law § 223-b.

Leave a Comment

This blog is ONLY for informational or educational purposes and DOES NOT substitute professional legal advise. We take no responsibility or credit for what you do with this info.